• Home
  • Checklists
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Have something you want us to publish? Click Here

Agency Checklists

Massachusetts Insurance News

  • Agency News
  • Insurer News
  • Fraud News
  • Latest Hires
  • RMV News
  • CAR News
  • DOI News

DOI Special Investigations & Enforcement Actions For 2017 Including the Fourth Quarter & Kilgore Consent Agreement

April 3, 2018 by Julia Ybarra

The Fourth Quarter includes enforcement actions during the months of October, November & December of this year.

Agency Checklists, MA Insurance News, Mass. Insurance News, Mass. Division of Insurance News, DOI News, Massachusetts insurance regulationsEach quarter, the Division of Insurance publishes a list of the enforcement actions it has taken against licensed Resident and Non-Resident Producers. The total fines assessed often vary depending on the circumstances and actions alleged.

The following is a review of the Fourth Quarter as well as a look back at the entire year of 2017, which includes special investigations and enforcement hearings during the months of October, November & December of 2017.

What was the total amount of actions and fines during the 4th  quarter of 2017?

The DOI Special Investigations Unit was involved in 10 investigations during the Fourth Quarter of 2017

The Fourth Quarter of 2017 saw an increase in the number of administrative actions as well as fines imposed by the Division of Insurance, relative to the Third Quarter, although the number is still far less than the First & Second Quarters of 2017. In this most recent quarter, which ended on December 31, 2017, the Division had a total of 10 enforcement actions.

Looking at the year in total, the Division of Insurance engaged in actions resulting in the issuance of $122,095 in fines.

Fines imposed during this Quarter totaled $10,000

As stated above, the total fines imposed this Quarter totaled $10,000. The following is a breakdown of the dollar amount of fines imposed during each quarter.

  • First Quarter: $96,695
  • Second Quarter: $15,370
  • Third Quarter: $30
  • Fourth Quarter: $10,000

As a result, the total fines for the entire year of 2017 still surpass the total dollar amount of fines imposed in 2016, which was $72,315.

What was the largest fine imposed 2017?

The largest fine imposed by the Division of Insurance occurred during the First Quarter of 2017. It was a $75,000 fine imposed against America Pet Insurance for Unlicensed Activity.

A look at the Kilgore Insurance Agency case in response to our readers’ requests

In response to various readers requests on the outcome of the Division’s Enforcement Action against the Kilgore Insurance Agency, Agency Checklists has obtained the results of the final resolution of the Division of Insurance proceedings involving this agency and its principals.

On August 16, 2012, the Division filed an Order to Show Cause against the Kilgore Insurance Agency, Cyrus Kilgores, Jeffrey Kilgore, Kathleen J. Burke, and Andrew W. Crowther. The Order to Show Cause as amended alleged, in part, that by signing insurance documents on behalf of clients without authority, the Kilgores used dishonest practices in the conduct of business in the Commonwealth.

The Division stayed its proceedings on the Order to Show Cause because of an ongoing lawsuit brought by the Attorney General alleging civil claims based on some of the same acts and conduct alleged by the Division in its Order to Show Cause.

On April 29, 2015, an amended final judgment was entered in the Civil Action against the Kilgores and their Agency in the amount of $2,183,637.30 plus statutory prejudgment interest at 12% per annum from December 22, 2009. See Agency Checklists’ article of May 4, 2015, “Court Orders $3.5 Million Restitution From Producer And Agency For Fees Exceeding 20% Of Premiums.”

Following the entry of judgment on the Attorney General’s civil suit, the Division lifted its stay on the Order to Show Cause and the Kilgores and the Agency together filed Answers to the Order to Show Cause on February 1, 2016 “…denying the allegations in the Order to Show Cause”.

In June 2017, the Division executed a Consent Agreement and Order with the Kilgores and the Agency. Under the terms of the Consent Agreement and Order, the parties stipulated the settlement agreement, “…is not an admission of wrongdoing, liability, or the truth of any of the disputed factual and legal allegations and claims asserted by the Division in this Consent Agreement or in the Order to Show Cause…”

As part of the Consent Agreement And Order entered into by the parties, the Agency, along with its proprietors Cyrus and Jeffrey Kilgore, agreed to pay a $20,000 fine which allowed the agency to settle the matter “…without admitting any wrongdoing or violation of insurance laws”. These fines were the second largest fines imposed in 2017 by the Division of Insurance.

The consent agreement and order only related to the Kilgores and the Kilgore Insurance Agency. As found in the above Agency Checklists article and the attached Superior Court judgment, the Superior Court judge found no direct liability against the Kilgores. Their liability was entirely vicarious based on the actions of their employee, Andrew Crowther.

The Order to Show Cause against Andrew Crother is open and active. The Division has scheduled hearings for April 11, April 12, and April 13 on the allegations against Mr. Crowther.

No Division proceedings appear to be active against the fourth individual, Kathleen J. Burke. In the civil action brought by the Attorney General, the Superior Court judge hearing the suit found no liability against Ms. Burke and specifically declared Ms. Burke was “not liable for any actions which she performed for [Andrew] Crowther.”

Any readers wishing to obtain a copy of the Consent Consent Agreement and Order between the Division of Insurance and the Kilgores and the Kilgore Insurance Agency, may request a copy by contacting Agency Checklists.

Fines involving Hearing Officer Decisions

During the last quarter of 2017, there were a few hearing decisions published by the Division of Insurance. On October 17, 2017, for example, the Division issued an order under General Laws Chapter 175, § 166B against Massachusetts Resident Producer, Carmen Chase Hunter, as well as fining her $2,000. For a detailed analysis of that case, please refer to Agency Checklists’ November 14, 2017, article entitled, “Mass. DOI Revokes Producer’s Licenses Rejecting Criminal Conspiracy Claim“.

In November of 2017, the Division issued an additional three hearing decisions involving producers in Massachusetts. The cases involved actions and fines against Michael S. Lainsey, of Jacksonville Beach, Florida, Lester G. Sherman, Jr., of Bloomfield Hills, Michigan, and Nadine A. Petrarca, of Warwick, Rhode Island resulting in various fines for each of these individuals. For an in-depth analysis of these decisions, please refer to Agency Checklists’ December 12, 2017, article entitled, “Mass. DOI Hearing Officer Revokes Three Producers’ Licenses And Fines Licensees Total Of $6,500“.

A look at the cases published during the Fourth Quarter

In addition to the cases highlighted above, the following is a complete list of the Administrative Actions conducted and reported during the Fourth Quarter 2017:

  1. Licensee & Type of Case: Resident Producer
    • Date: November 17, 2017
    • Allegations: Violation of Insurance Laws; Trustworthiness
    • Disposition: Settlement Agreement
    • Fine: N/A
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  2. Licensee & Type of Case: Sherika Brantley, Non-Resident Producer
    • Date: December 6, 2017
    • Allegations: License Revoked in Another State; Failure to Report Administrative Action
    • Disposition: Hearing Officer Decision
    • Fine: $1,000
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  3. Licensee & Type of Case: Non-Resident Producer
    • Date: December 6, 2017
    • Allegations: License Revoked in Another State; Failure to Report Administrative Action
    • Disposition: Hearing Officer Decision
    • Fine: $500
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  4. Licensee & Type of Case: Carmen Chase Hunter, Resident Producer
    • Date: October 17, 2017
    • Allegations: Trustworthiness; Failure to Report Administrative Action; Violation of Insurance Laws; Misrepresentation on License Application
    • Disposition: Hearing Officer Decision
    • Fine: $2000
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  5. Licensee & Type of Case: Rodolfo Jimenez, Non-Resident Producer
    • Date: December 6, 2017
    • Allegations: Violation of Insurance Laws; License Revoked in Another State; Failure to Report Administrative Action
    • Disposition: Hearing Officer Decision
    • Fine: $3,000
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  6. Licensee & Type of Case: Michael Laisney, Non-Resident Producer
    • Date: November 24, 2017
    • Allegations: License Revoked in Another State; Failure to Report Administrative Action
    • Disposition: Hearing Officer Decision
    • Fine: N/A
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  7. Licensee & Type of Case: Nadine Petrarca, Non-Resident Producer
    • Date: November 30, 2017
    • Allegations: License Revoked in Another State; Failure to Report Administrative Action
    • Disposition: Hearing Officer Decision
    • Fine: $2,500
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  8. Licensee & Type of Case: Valenzia Ramsey, Non-Resident Producer
    • Date: December 6, 2017
    • Allegations: License Revoked in Another State; Failure to Report Administrative Action
    • Disposition: Hearing Officer Decision
    • Fine: $1000
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  9. Licensee & Type of Case: Sherman Lester, Non-Resident Producer
    • Date: November 30, 2017
    • Allegations: License Revoked in Another State; Failure to Report Administrative Action
    • Disposition: Hearing Officer Decision
    • Fine: $1000
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  10. Licensee & Type of Case: Resident Producer
    • Date: December 18, 2017
    • Allegations: Misrepresentation on License Application; Violation of Insurance Laws; Trustworthiness; Unfair or Deceptive Act in Business of Insurance
    • Disposition: Settlement Agreement
    • Fine: N/A
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist
  11. Licensee & Type of Case: Non-Resident Producer
    • Date: December 6, 2017
    • Allegations: Violation of Insurance Laws; License Revoked in Another State; Failure to Report Administrative Action
    • Disposition: Hearing Officer Decision
    • Fine: $1,500
    • Licensing Action: Revocation; Cease & Desist

The Division’s Special Investigation Unit is in charge of investigating producers

While the primary mission of the Division of Insurance is “…to monitor the solvency of its licensees in order to promote a healthy, responsive and willing marketplace for consumers who purchase insurance products” a major part of that mission involves insurance enforcement. The DOI engages in a variety of administrative actions throughout the year in order to ensure that the insurance industry and its representatives maintain a just and healthy marketplace.

In the ordinary course of the Division of Insurance regulating the Massachusetts insurance industry, the Division’s Special Investigation Unit will pursue allegations of misconduct against any persons licensed by the DOI including:

  • insurance producers;
  • insurance advisers; public adjusters;
  • reinsurance intermediaries;
  • viatical loan brokers and providers;
  • viatical settlement brokers and providers;
  • insurance companies; health maintenance organizations; and,
  • self-insurance groups.

As part of its investigation, the Division’s Special Investigation Unit may interview witnesses, question licensees, demand and review documentary evidence supporting allegations of unfair methods of competition or unfair trade practices or any other violation of the insurance law.

If a specific investigation warrants further action, egregious cases may result in a referral to the Attorney General’s office. In less serious cases the Division independently may negotiate settlements or request the Commissioner or his deputies to initiate an administrative proceeding before a hearing officer, issue a cease and desist order or compel written compliance programs.  In more egregious cases, a licensee’s conduct may warrant sanctions including license revocations or suspensions along with restitution and possible fines.

To learn more about avoiding enforcement issues, you may be interested in Agency Checklists’ May 2, 2011 article “One Way to Avoid Large Fines for You & Your Agency.”

 

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • LinkedIn

Filed Under: DOI News, License hearings Tagged With: kilgore insurance agency, License enforcement actions against Mass. agents, ma insurance news, mass division of insurance, Mass. insurance agent investigations, Mass. Insurance News, Massagent Insurance Reviews

Leave A Comment or Question

  1. Frank A. Lombard CPCU ARM says

    April 3, 2018 at 10:20 AM

    It’s really troubling to me how the DOI’s Special Investigation Unit can punish agents for misrepresentations on their application while ignoring home insurers inflating required amounts of insurance and charging inflated premiums to millions of Massachusetts homeowners. Although DOI approved policy forms base required amounts of insurance on the cost to build a home BEFORE it has been damaged, the Division permits insurers to use the “inflated” cost to rebuild AFTER a loss has occurred. Doesn’t it seem like someone should be investigating the investigators?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Upcoming Events

  1. MAIA: YAC Trivia Night

    April 24 @ 5:30 PM - 7:30 PM
  2. CAR: Commercial Auto Residual Market Standards Subcommittee Meeting

    April 25 @ 10:30 AM - 12:30 PM
  3. W.I.N.E.: Sipping with a Purpose: 2018 Beer and Wine Tasting

    May 3 @ 5:00 PM - 8:00 PM

View All Events

Post or Find a Job Here

The Latest From Our Job Board

  • HUB International New England, LLC

    Producer

    • East Longmeadow, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    High Net Worth Insurance Producer

    • Wilmington, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    High Net Worth – Private Client Group – Account Manager

    • Wilmington, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    Client Relationship Manager

    • Wilmington, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    Assistant Account Manager

    • Norwell, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    Commercial Insurance Account Manager

    • Fall River, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • Hartshorne & Curley Insurance, Inc.

    Customer Service – P/L & C/L

    • Wakefield, MA
    • Hartshorne & Curley Insurance, Inc.
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    VIP Personal Insurance Account Manager

    • Wilmington, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    Commercial Insurance Account Manager

    • Wilmington, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    Commercial Insurance Account Manager – Construction

    • Fall River, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    Personal Insurance Account Manager

    • Chatham, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • HUB International New England, LLC

    Personal Lines Manager

    • Norwell, MA
    • HUB International New England, LLC
  • Rogers & Gray Insurance

    Account Manager, Business Insurance- Construction

    • Kingston, MA
    • Rogers & Gray Insurance
  • Merchants Insurance Group

    Regional Claim Supervisor

    • Bedford, New Hampshire
    • Merchants Insurance Group
  • Kaplansky Insurance Agency

    Personal Lines Account Manager

    • Brookline, MA
    • Kaplansky Insurance Agency
  • Kaplansky Insurance Agency

    Property & Casualty Agency Manager

    • Marlboro,MA
    • Kaplansky Insurance Agency
  • Kaplansky Insurance Agency

    Commercial Lines Account Manager

    • Haverill, MA
    • Kaplansky Insurance Agency
  • Gaudette Insurance Agency

    Commercial Lines CSR

    • Whitinsville, MA
    • Gaudette Insurance Agency
  • Norfolk & Dedham Group

    Physical Damage Claims Examiner

    • Dedham, MA
    • Norfolk & Dedham Group

Checklists

  • Applying For An Agency Loan
  • Deciding Whether or Not to Outsource Your Agency’s Customer Service? Read This Checklist First.
  • Employment Contracts & The Non-Compete Clause In Massachusetts
  • Hiring An Insurance Producer In Massachusetts
  • Insurance Agent to Agency Loans In Massachusetts
  • Moving Your Massachusetts Insurance Agency
  • Opting To Use Premium Financing In Your Massachusetts Insurance Agency
  • Purchasing An Agency
  • Remuneration Audit Checklist
  • Selling Your Massachusetts Insurance Agency
  • Starting A Massachusetts Insurance Agency
  • When The Auditor Calls
  • Why, When, & How An Agent Should Use A Business Broker

Article Comments & Updates

  • Jane Logan MA Division of Insurance MPIUA 4/19/18 hearing cancelled "The State Rating Bureau advised me this morning that the parties to this proceeding have been negotiating a possible settlement, and therefore will not cross-examine the FAIR PLAN’s actuarial witness on April 19. For that reason, tomorrow’s... Apr 18, 11:26 AM
  • Agency Checklists Thanks for your inquiry. It looks like as of 2018 Swyfft is live in Texas. Here is a screenshot from their Facebook page which shows all of the states where Swyfft is currently available. Hope that helps. null Apr 04, 3:52 PM
  • Frank A. Lombard CPCU ARM It’s really troubling to me how the DOI’s Special Investigation Unit can punish agents for misrepresentations on their application while ignoring home insurers inflating required amounts of insurance and charging inflated premiums to millions of Massachusetts homeowners. Although DOI approved policy forms base required amounts... Apr 03, 10:20 AM
  • Ron Wright Are you doing business in the state of Texas? Apr 01, 5:36 PM

Top Posts & Pages

  • A New Insurtech That Swyfft-ly Quotes Homeowners Insurance In Seconds For Independent Agents
    A New Insurtech That Swyfft-ly Quotes Homeowners Insurance In Seconds For Independent Agents
  • $2 Million E&O Verdict Against Taunton Agency And Its President
    $2 Million E&O Verdict Against Taunton Agency And Its President
  • New Law Sets $47,476 As Minimum Salary for Overtime
    New Law Sets $47,476 As Minimum Salary for Overtime
  • Massachusetts Insurance Jobs
    Massachusetts Insurance Jobs
  • Appeals Court Takes Aim At “Retail Book Value” For Total Losses Under MA Auto Policy
    Appeals Court Takes Aim At “Retail Book Value” For Total Losses Under MA Auto Policy
  • Five Key Points About The Allstate Exclusive Agency Agreement
    Five Key Points About The Allstate Exclusive Agency Agreement
  • The Final 2017 Numbers On The Top 20 Private Passenger Auto Insurers In Massachusetts
    The Final 2017 Numbers On The Top 20 Private Passenger Auto Insurers In Massachusetts
  • The Top Twenty Workers' Comp Carriers In The Commonwealth
    The Top Twenty Workers' Comp Carriers In The Commonwealth
  • If You Can't Beat 'Em, Join 'Em? GEICO Hiring Local Agents In Massachusetts
    If You Can't Beat 'Em, Join 'Em? GEICO Hiring Local Agents In Massachusetts
  • Erin Deveney Officially Appointed RMV Registrar
    Erin Deveney Officially Appointed RMV Registrar

© 2015 Agencychecklists | Disclaimer

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.