• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Contact Us
  • Sponsor An Email
  • Post A Job
  • Merger & Acquisition Services

Agency Checklists

Massachusetts Insurance News & Job Opportunities

You are here: Home / Latest News / Court Asked To Certify Classes Totaling Over 80,000 IDV Claims Against Commerce and Safety

Court Asked To Certify Classes Totaling Over 80,000 IDV Claims Against Commerce and Safety

June 13, 2023 by Owen Gallagher


In the protracted legal battle pertaining to the recovery of inherent diminished value (IDV) damages under Part Four of the standard Massachusetts 2008 automobile policy form, the two respective litigants against Commerce Insurance and Safety Insurance requested the Business Litigation Session of the Superior Court on June 7, 2023, to certify two classes.

The classes the Plaintiffs are asking the Court to allow them to represent would include the following:

All individual third-party claimants who:

A. Suffered a property damage loss as a result of a Commerce/Safety Insured or Commerce/Safety Insured vehicle driver.

B. Safety determined that its insured (or insured vehicle driver) was/were legally liable for the property damage to the claimant’s automobile.

C. Commerce/Safety has already paid the third-party property damage claim, either to the claimant, the repair shop, or subrogating insurer (or other person or entity).

D. The claimant’s vehicle suffered damage at or in excess of $500.00 as a result of the collision.

Supposedly classes of 50,000 and 30,000 unpaid IDV claims involved in these lawsuits

According to the Plaintiffs, discovery showed that during the relevant time period for the class action suit, Commerce processed 472,669 third-party automobile property damage claims. Of these claims, the Commerce Plaintiff has asserted, more than 50,000 involved third-party property damage claims where Commerce determined its insureds were liable but for which Commerce did not pay any inherent diminished value damages.

Likewise, the discovery allegedly showed that Safety processed 33,172 third-party automobile property damage claims, during which Safety determined its insured was liable for the loss.

A screenshot of the 2008 Mass Auto Policy

The Supreme Judicial Court ruled in 2021 that IDV damages were recoverable on third-party auto property damage claims

The Plaintiffs’ lawsuits claiming that inherent diminished value damages were recoverable under the 2008 addition of the Massachusetts standard policy were filed in 2017 against Safety and in 2018 against Commerce. The lawsuits were consolidated and proceeded to summary judgment. The Superior Court ruled against the Plaintiffs, and they appealed.

The Supreme Judicial Court reversed the Superior Court and found that IDV damages were recoverable under the 2008 version of the standard Massachusetts automobile policy. See Agency Checklists’ article of October 26, 2021, “Supreme Court Rules Auto Policies Cover Vehicles’ Post-Repair Losses of Value.”

The final order of the Supreme Judicial Court returned the Plaintiffs’ cases to the Business Litigation Session of the Superior Court for the Plaintiffs to prove their damages.

After extensive discovery, the critical factor for the Plaintiffs and their counsel is whether they can establish their lawsuits as class actions.

The Plaintiffs’ Motion to certify classes of IDV claimants

In order to certify these lawsuits as class actions, the Business Litigation Session judge will have to find the proposed classes fulfill the following conditions:

  1. The proposed class is sufficiently numerous to make the joinder of all parties impractical.
  2. There are common questions of law and fact among the members of the proposed class.
  3. The claim of the named plaintiff representative is typical of the claims of the proposed class’s members; and
  4. The named plaintiff will fairly and adequately represent the interests of the class.

The Plaintiffs have the burden of satisfying the Court that these factors apply and warrant the Court certifying the requested classes.

Both Commerce and Safety have presented strong arguments in their opposition to the Plaintiffs satisfying these class action requirements.

Agency Checklists will keep its readers apprised of these important consolidated cases.

Best insurance lawyers Massachusetts

Owen Gallagher

Insurance Coverage Legal Expert/Co-Founder & Publisher of Agency Checklists

Over the course of my legal career, I have argued a number of cases in the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court as well as helped agents, insurance companies, and lawmakers alike with the complexities and idiosyncrasies of insurance law in the Commonwealth.

Connect with me directly, by calling me at 617-598-3801.

    Print Friendly, PDF & Email

    Filed Under: Latest News, MA Insurance Law | Insurance Coverage Cases Tagged With: Agency Checklists, insurance news massachusetts, Mass. Insurance News, massachusetts insurance news, New England Insurance News

    About Owen Gallagher

    Owen Gallagher is an experienced insurance litigator as well as a certified mediator and arbitrator who specializes in insurance industry disputes. His interest and affinity for insurance began at a young age working the counter at his father’s assigned risk agency in Roxbury. Over the course of his career, Owen has argued a number of cases in the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court and has helped agents, insurance companies, and lawmakers alike with the complexities and idiosyncrasies of insurance law in the Commonwealth.  Owen can be reached here.

    Primary Sidebar

    Massachusetts Division of Insurance Announcement

    Sponsored

    Latest Agency Sales

    Gallagher Snaps Up Eastern In Sale Worth 5-Times Commissions

    Salem Five Insurance Acquires Philbin Insurance Group

    Salem Five Insurance Acquires Philbin Insurance Group

    More Agency Sales

    Career News

    Fred C. Church Hires Accomplished Higher Education Risk Management Professional Damual Greaves As Client Executive, Commercial Lines

    New Hampshire Insurance Department Announces Confirmation of DJ Bettencourt as Insurance Commissioner

    New Hampshire Insurance Department Announces Confirmation of DJ Bettencourt as Insurance Commissioner

    NAIC Now Accepting Applications for 2024 Consumer Representatives

    Boston Bruins Defenseman Hampus Lindholm Joins Plymouth Rock Assurance as Brand Ambassador for 2023-24 NHL Season

    Boston Bruins Defenseman Hampus Lindholm Joins Plymouth Rock Assurance as Brand Ambassador for 2023-24 NHL Season 

    Charles Symington Becomes Big ‘I’ President & CEO

    The Hanover Appoints Stephanie E. Seibold and Arthur J. Barrett to Key Specialty Leadership Roles

    Michelle Raue, SVP & Chief Claims Officer for Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Appointed to Rise Advisory Board of Directors

    Fred C. Church Announces Key Personnel Changes to its Education Team

    Kaplansky Insurance Appoints Peter Kenyon as Chief Acquisition Officer

    The Hanover Appoints Charles F. Hamann to President of Small Commercial

    View More Career News

    In Memoriam

    Robert J. Barnat

    In Memoriam: Robert J. Barnat, 1946-2023

    In Memoriam: Bernard Gitlin

    In Memoriam: Pauline R. Gifford, 1936-2023

    CAR News

    DOI Approves CAR’s Changes in Massachusetts Auto Insurance Claims Handling

    3rd Look At The 2023 Commercial Auto Marketplace in Massachusetts

    Ballot Law Campaign Opposes Industry-Backed Auto Repair Agreement

    View More CAR News

    Massachusetts Law Updates

    Claims-Made Policy Snares Another: Preservation Trust Loses Coverage For Late Notice

    Strict Construction of Claims-Made Policy Strikes Again

    Agency Checklists, MA Insurance News, Mass. Insurance News

    Appeal Denied: Allstate Agents’ Wrongful Termination Claim Falls Flat

    A case involving two former Allstate agents allegedly misusing confidential customer data after their termination.

    Harvard College Sues Zurich to Overturn A Late Notice Denial of A $15 Million Policy Claim

    The Pitfall of Late Notice: Harvard’s $15 Million Coverage Loss

    The lawsuit over Harvard’s admission policies discriminating against Asian-American applicants.

    Agency Checklists, MA Insurance News, Mass. Insurance News, GEICO, Largest Auto Insurance Cos. in Massachusetts

    GEICO Faces Legal Battle as Captive Agent’s Lawsuit Advances

    A Captive Agent’s Suit Against GEICO Can Proceed on Claims of Breach of Contract, Renewal Commissions Owed, Unjust Enrichment, and Employee Misclassification

    More Mass. Law Updates

    DOI News

    Home Insurance Report Part III: Policies by Massachusetts County

    MA Homeowners’ Insurance Premiums Topped $2.8B in 2021

    Massachusetts Remains The 14th Largest Insurance Marketplace As Ranked By Total Premium Volume

    Facts & Figures For New England Insurance Departments & Insurance Producers | 2023

    View More DOI News

    Insurance Fraud

    Prison For A Year-And-A-Day in $14 Million Payroll Tax and Insurance Fraud Case

    Greed & Betrayal: 67-year-old Advisor Gets 4 Years For Annuity Thefts From Vulnerable Clients

    Physical Therapy Assistant Sentenced in Massachusetts Auto No-Fault Insurance Fraud Scheme

    Surprising Survey Results Show Many Americans Think Insurance Fraud Is Not A Crime

    More Insurance Fraud News

    Footer

    Agency Checklists

    Contact us

    Advertise on Agency Checklists

    We offer a variety of ways to get help promote your company or product.

    Announcements
    Email Sponsorships
    Partnerships
    Custom Collaborations

    *Affiliate Disclosure

    Please note that any of Agency Checklists’ articles might contain one or more affiliate links. This means that any subsequent purchase resulting from these links may result in a commission for us, but at no additional cost to you. For example, as an Amazon Associate, Agency Checklists earns a commission from all qualifying purchases. By working with affiliates we can continue to keep Agency Checklists subscription free. Thank you for your support.

    SEARCH OUR SITE

    Explore Our Archives

    Copyright © 2023 · Agency Checklists · All rights reserved.

     

    Loading Comments...