• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Contact Us
  • Sponsor An Email
  • Post A Job
  • Merger & Acquisition Services

Agency Checklists

Massachusetts Insurance News & More

You are here: Home / Insurance Insights | Massachusetts / InsurOp-Eds / InSurOp-Ed: In Claim Disputes, Disregard Case Law At Your Own Risk

InSurOp-Ed: In Claim Disputes, Disregard Case Law At Your Own Risk

May 10, 2022 by Bill Wilson

Legal Decision


The International Risk Management Institute has several free newsletters. Recently, I received my copy of the IRMI Construction Risk Manager newsletter which featured a court case, Security Nat’l Ins. Co. v. Construction Assoc. of Spokane, No. 2:20-cv-00167, 2022 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 53533 (E.D. Wash. Mar. 24, 2022), that involved whether a general contractor was an additional insured under a subcontractor’s CGL policy.

But the issue I’d like to address in this article is, according to newsletter editor Ann Hickman, CPCU, CRIS, ARM, the court’s holding the insurer “in bad faith for denying a claim without making a reasonable attempt to review the legal precedent cited by the insured’s counsel.” According to Ann, the court held that “insurance companies must take reasonable steps to ensure adjusters are equipped to make appropriate coverage and defense determinations. ‘Such steps could include teaching adjusters to run case searches or, more likely, supplying adjusters with subscriptions to relevant legal newsletters, a resource most attorneys rely on to keep apprised of legal developments,’ the court opinion states.”

I make precisely this point in my book “When Words Collide: Resolving Insurance Coverage and Claims Disputes.” In the book, I devote over 70 pages to 17 legal and contractual principles that can be used to resolve such disputes. One of these principles is what I refer to as “Unconscionable Advantage.”

In my discussion of this principle, I cite the following court case:

“In situations where a layman might give the controlling language of the policy a more restrictive interpretation than the insurer knows the courts have given it and, as a result, the uninformed insured might be inclined to be quiescent about the disregard or non-payment of his claim and not to press it in timely fashion, the company cannot ignore its obligation. It cannot hide behind the insured’s ignorance of the law; it cannot conceal its liability. In these circumstances it has the duty to speak and disclose, and to act in accordance with its contractual undertaking.” — Bowler v. Fidelity & Cas. Co., 53 N.J. 313, 327-328, 250 A.2d 580, 588 (1969)

More specific to the Security National decision referenced in the IRMI newsletter, the Bowler decision expresses how important and valuable governing case law can be to a claim. If the insurer is made aware of case law under identical or significantly similar circumstances where coverage has been found, it is with great risk that it continues to deny the claim. In fact, consider the following case cited in my book [emphasis added]:

“An insurer bears a duty to defend its insured whenever it ascertains facts which give rise to the potential of liability under the policy irrespective of the source of the information.” — Smith v. Travelers Indem. Co., 32 Cal. App. 3d 1010, 1017, 108 Cal. Rptr. 643 (Ct. App. 5th Dist. 1973)

The adjuster and insurer failed to acknowledge the case law cited by the claimant’s attorney. Governing case law is often critical to resolving claim disputes and, as the Security National case illustrates, this does not mean just the case law one party believes supports its opinion.

Finally, as my book in its entirety demonstrates, not only is case law of value, but ANY reputable source of credible, substantive and material authority may be relevant.

Agency Checklists, MA Insurance News, Mass. Insurance News, Bill Wilson, Insurance Commentary

Bill Wilson, CPCU, ARM, AIM, AAM

Founder at InsuranceCommentary.com

One of the premier insurance educators in America on form, coverage, and technical issues; Founder and director of the Big “I” Virtual University; Retired Assoc. VP of Education and Research from Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America.

Copyright 2016-2021 by InsuranceCommentary.com. Reprinted with permission.

  • Website
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Filed Under: InsurOp-Eds, Latest News Tagged With: Agency Checklists, Bill Wilson, Mass. Insurance News, New England Insurance News

Primary Sidebar

Sponsored

Sponsored

Latest Agency Sales

Patriot Growth Adds Two Employee Benefit Agencies in Massachusetts

Cross Insurance Acquires Two More Massachusetts Insurance Agencies & Opens A New Office in Newburyport

Q1-2022 Sees A Decline in U.S. Mergers & Acquisitions Activity

Insurance Agency Mergers & Acquisitions in Mass. | Q1-2022

Insurance Agency Mergers & Acquisitions in Mass. | Q1-2022

More Agency Sales

Career News

Two New Appointments At Preferred Mutual

Agency Checklists, MA Insurance News, Mass. Insurance News, MA Life Insurance Companies, Boston Mutual

Boston Mutual Life Insurance Company Appoints David Martin as Vice President and Chief Information Officer

Satellite Agency Network

SAN Group Announces Recipients of 2022 SAN Awards

Alera Group Expands Northeast Regional Leadership Team

A.I.M. Mutual Elects Daniel A. Landers President & Chief Executive Officer

A.I.M. Mutual Elects Daniel A. Landers President & Chief Executive Officer

In Memoriam

In Memoriam: Daniel Rizzo, 1937-2022

In Memoriam: Bruce MacDonald 1935-2022

In Memoriam: Bruce MacDonald 1935-2022

In Memoriam: William "Bill" Carter, Jr. 1932-2022

In Memoriam: William “Bill” Carter, Jr. 1932-2022

CAR News

17 Bullet Points on The New Insurance Labor Rate Report

2nd Look 2022: The Massachusetts Private Passenger Auto Insurance Marketplace

2nd Look 2022: The Commercial Auto Insurance Marketplace in Massachusetts

1st Look 2022: The Commercial Auto Insurance Marketplace in Massachusetts

View More CAR News

Massachusetts Law Updates

Front view of the Quincy Mass. Masonic Temple with Roman Columns

Confused Voicemail Leads to E&O and Coverage Suits

SJC Construed For 1st Time Meaning of “Doing Business As” In Relation to CGL Coverage.

5 Points On New Ruling: Unreasonable Storage Reduces ACV Payment

A short opinion with a disproportionate impact on first-party property damage total loss claims.

Agency Checklist article on COVID-19 Closings in Massachusetts

First State High-Court COVID-19 Decision On Business Interruption Claims

Dismissed by Superior Court, the restaurants took their appeal directly to the SJC.

Vermont Mutual Asks High Court to Reverse Decision $215,000 Attorney Fee Award Payable As Damages under Bodily Injury Coverage

An unusual case involving a breach of warranty claim under Chapter 93A and whether mandatory attorney fee awards apply.

More Mass. Law Updates

DOI News

The 2022 MA Home Insurance Report Part II | MA FAIR Plan Review

The 2022 MA Home Insurance Report | Part I

Mass. Business Entity License Renewals on Hold

DOI Fines Producer $1,250 For Prior Failures To Report After License Lapses

View More DOI News

Insurance Fraud

Quinn Group Ins. Owner’s Trial to Begin on Federal Benefit and Social Security Fraud Today

First Guilty Plea in No-Fault PIP Auto Insurance Fraud Scheme

GM Financial Will Pay Over $1.8 Million For GAP Coverage Refunds and Loan Violations

Insurance Agency To Pay $100,000 Fine And $515,000 In Restitution Under Consent Decree

More Insurance Fraud News

Footer

Agency Checklists

About us
Contact us

14 Summer Street
Suite 102
Malden, MA 02148
617-598-3800

Advertise on Agency Checklists

We offer a variety of ways to get help promote your company or product.

Announcements
Email Sponsorships
Partnerships
Custom Collaborations

*Affiliate Disclosure

Please note that any of Agency Checklists’ articles might contain one or more affiliate links. This means that any subsequent purchase resulting from these links may result in a commission for us, but at no additional cost to you. For example, as an Amazon Associate, Agency Checklists earns a commission from all qualifying purchases. By working with affiliates we can continue to keep Agency Checklists subscription free. Thank you for your support.

SEARCH OUR SITE

Explore Our Archives

Copyright © 2022 · Agency Checklists · All rights reserved.

 

Loading Comments...