Who Are The Top Commercial Auto Insurance Companies in Massachusetts?

This list is based on data compiled by the DOI for 2016, the last year for which complete data is available.

This week we turn to review who are the top commercial automobile insurance companies in the Commonwealth. The information reprinted here was provided by The Massachusetts Division of Insurance based on data collected during the calendar year 2016, the last year for which complete information is available.

There are currently 212 companies writing this line of insurance in Massachusetts

Two hundred and twelve (212) companies currently write Commercial Auto in Massachusetts claiming Total Direct Premium of $835,082,080 dollars.

Six out of the top 20 Commercial Automobile Insurance Companies are Massachusetts-based

The top 20 Commercial Auto insurance companies in the Commonwealth have a combined total of $547,057,695 dollars in Direct Written Premium. This amount represents a 65.5% share of the market.

Out of the top 20 companies writing this line of insurance, six are based in Massachusetts.

They are as follows:

1. MAPFRE/Commerce;
2. Arbella Protection Ins. Co.;
3. Safety Insurance Co.;
4. Safety Ind. Ins. Co.;
5. Citation Ins. Co.; and
6. Pilgrim Ins. Co.

The remaining 192 companies writing commercial auto here have Direct Written Premium totaling $288,023,385 dollars representing a 34.5% share of the market.

Premium Written and MA Market Share of the top 20 Commercial Auto Insurers

Company Name	State	Premium Written in MA	Market Share in MA
Commerce Ins. Co.	MA	103,674,495	12.41%
Arbella Protection Ins Co	MA	$81,370,355	9.74%
Safety Ins Co	MA	$78,787,332	9.43%
Charter Oak Fire Ins Co	CT	$58,341,308	6.99%
Safety Ind Ins Co	MA	$35,832,464	4.29%
Philadelphia Ind Ins Co	PA	$28,280,748	3.39%
Allmerica Fin Benefit Ins Co	MI	$14,960,223	1.79%
Liberty Mut Fire Ins Co	WI	$13,429,035	1.61%
Travelers Cas Ins Co Of Amer	CT	$13,421,794	1.61%
NGM Ins Co	FL	$12,774,248	1.53%
Acadia Ins Co	NH	$12,618,456	1.51%
Pilgrim Ins Co	MA	$12,443,677	1.49%
Citation Ins Co	MA	$12,156,690	1.46%
New Hampshire Ins Co	IL	$11,857,827	1.42%
Progressive Cas Ins Co	OH	$11,366,096	1.36%
Zurich Amer Ins Co	NY	$11,316,055	1.36%
Travelers Ind Co	CT	$10,358,271	1.24%
National Interstate Ins Co	OH	$8,318,932	1.00%
Union Ins Co	IA	$7,901,866	0.95%
National Union Fire Ins Co Of Pitts	PA	$7,847,823	0.94%