• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Contact Us
  • Post A Job

Agency Checklists

Massachusetts Insurance News & Job Opportunities

  • AC Interviews
  • Agency M&A
  • Career News
  • CAR News
  • DOI News
  • Coverage Cases
  • Innovation
  • InsurOp-Eds
  • AC Podcast
You are here: Home / Market Share Reports & Industry Trends / MA Market Share Reports / The Top 20 Writers of Fire Insurance In Massachusetts

The Top 20 Writers of Fire Insurance In Massachusetts

May 14, 2019 by Agency Checklists

As we have done in the Spring over the past few years, over the course of the next couple of weeks, Agency Checklists will take a look at the current market shares and overall state of various lines of insurance operating within the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. As always, all of our information comes courtesy of the Division of Insurance, which is charged with compiling and issue an annual report outlining the current state of the insurance marketplace in Massachusetts each year.

Nicholas Barbon, the father of modern-day fire insurance

Photo source: Wikipedia

We thought it might be interesting to our readers to include a little bit of history this year about the actual origins of fire insurance.

According to the Encyclopedia Britannica, English economist, Nicholas Barbon, is widely considered the founder of modern-day fire insurance. Born in London in 1640, he received his M.D. in medicine from the University of Leiden in Utrecht, in 1661. In 1664, he became an honorary fellow of the College of Physicians. It was his experience during London’s Great Fire of 1666, however, and the “considerable part” he took in the rebuilding efforts in its aftermath, which inspired Barbon to start selling this new line of insurance. In about 1680, he set up an office in London, appropriately titled, “Insurance Office for Houses” where he officially sold fire insurance. As a result, the following is how we know define fire insurance today:

Fire insurance, provision against losses caused by fire, lightning, and the removal of property from premises endangered by fire. The insurer agrees, for a fee, to reimburse the insured in the event of such an occurrence. The standard policy limits coverage to the replacement cost of the property destroyed less a depreciation allowance. Indirect loss, such as that resulting from the interruption of business, are excluded but may be covered under a separate contract. Insurance rates are influenced by the quality of fire protection available where the building is located, the type of building construction, the kind of activity conducted within the building, and the degree to which the building is exposed to losses originating outside it.

As for the current state of fire insurance in Massachusetts, the following information reflects the current composition of this marketplace as of 2017, the most recent year for which complete data is available.

fire insurance in Massachusetts
Charles Simms, March 17, 1796, Fire Insurance Policy.

Facts about the Fire Insurance Market Place in Massachusetts:

  • One-hundred and ninety-five (195) insurance companies are currently licensed to write Fire Insurance in Massachusetts. This is 73 companies less than the two-hundred and sixty-eight (268) insurance companies who were licensed to write this line of insurance in 2016.
  • The total Direct Written Premium for these 195 insurers in 2017 was $262,672,681. Of note, the total is approximately $43,671,916 less than the total Direct Written Premium of 2016.
  • Of note to those readers interested in the evolution of this particular market, the market share percentage of the top 20 insurance companies selling fire insurance in the Commonwealth has increased while its premiums decreased, as a result of the overall decrease in Written Premium for this line of business.
  • Specifically, in 2016, this group of insurers enjoyed a 66.1% share of the marketplace, writing a total of $202,541,287 dollars in Direct Written Premium. As of 2017, while this group of top 20 insurers now enjoys a 73.4% share of the marketplace, there total Written Premium totaled $192,896,711.
  • The remaining 175 insurers claims the remaining 26.6%% share of this market with Direct Premium Written totaling of $262,672,681 dollars.

Are there any top insurers that are based in Massachusetts as well?

  • Yes. There are five Massachusetts-based companies that are included in the top 20 list of the fire insurance companies, including top-ranked Arbella with a 12.30% market share followed by Commerce/MAPFRE Insurance with 8.29% and Lexington Insurance with a 5.37% market share. The following is the complete list of the top 20 fire insurers along with the amount of premium written and the corresponding market share.

The list of the top 20 in the fire insurance marketplace

Company Name

State

Premium Written in MA

Market Share in MA

1. Arbella Protection Ins Co 

MA

$32,308,824

12.30%

2. Commerce Ins Co 

MA

$21,774,934

8.29%

3. Lexington Ins Co 

MA

$14,115,622

5.37%

4. Vermont Mut Ins Co

VT

$13,226,143

5.04%

5. Affiliated Fm Ins Co

RI

$12,563,272

4.78%

6. North Amer Elite Ins Co

NH

$11,972,648

4.56%

7. Factory Mut Ins Co

RI

$10,199,805

3.88%

8. American Home Assur Co

NY

$9,889,626

3.76%

9. Liberty Mut Fire Ins Co

WI

$8,680,311

3.30%

10. American Security Ins Co

DE

$8,651,154

3.29%

11. Travelers Ind Co

CT

$8,068,221

3.07%

12. Arbella Mut Ins Co

MA

$6,215,922

2.37%

13. Metropolitan Prop & Cas Ins Co

RI

$5,073,303

1.93%

14. Zurich Amer Ins Co

NY

$4,957,008

1.89%

15. Foremost Ins Co Grand Rapids MI

MI

$4,950,551

1.88%

16. Farm Family Cas Ins Co

NY

$4,688,241

1.78%

17. AXA Ins Co

NY

$4,343,001

1.65%

18. Safety Ins Co

MA

$4,283,868

1.63%

19. Insurance Co Of The State of PA

IL

$3,560,531

1.36%

20. American Guar & Liab Ins

NY

$3,373,726

1.28%

Primary Sidebar

Job Board

Career News

Liberty Mutual construction insurance leadership focusing on large infrastructure and commercial projects

Liberty Mutual Insurance Appoints Amy Gross General Manager, North American Construction

Maine Bureau of Insurance leadership transition as Superintendent Robert Carey announces retirement

Maine Bureau of Insurance Announces Retirement of Superintendent Robert Carey

Arbella Insurance has appointed Jon Swartz as vice president and chief actuary.

Arbella Appoints New Vice President, Chief Actuary

Professional headshot of a smiling man in a blue suit against a dark gray background.

Jeffrey C. Johnston Named NAIC Chief Executive Officer 

View All

Listen Now

Sponsor

Interviews

From Nuptials, Tickets, and Taxes to Trusted Advisor: One Agency’s Unique Path to P&C Success

A Conversation with Evan Silverio, President & CEO of Silverio Insurance Group

Deland, Gibson Celebrates 125 Years: A Conversation with CEO Chip Gibson

The Fourth-Generation Family-Owned Agency is Based in Wellesley

Talking with Richard Welch: Growth and Innovation at Hospitality Mutual | Agency Checklists

Talking with Richard Welch: Growth and Innovation at Hospitality Mutual

Mr. Welch is CEO of Massachusetts-based Hospitality Insurance Group

Born and Bred in the Bay State: The Special Agent Story

Our Latest Agency Interview is with the Founder & President of Special Agent

A Conversation with Daniel C. Bridge – The 2023 Insurance Professional of the Year

Daniel Bridge is Board Chair, President, and CEO of Vermont Mutual Insurance Group

Making The Leap From Corporate to Entrepreneur: Nadeen Vella On Building NaVella Insurance From Scratch

Making The Leap From Corporate to Entrepreneur: Nadeen Vella On Building NaVella Insurance From Scratch

Our latest Agency Interview is with Nadeen Vella, the founder and owner of a virtual scratch independent agency.

View All

InsurOp-Eds

Bindable President Jean Marie Lovett

Bouncing Back: Working to Recover and Rebuild Following COVID-19

By Jean-Marie Lovett

InSurOp-Ed: When Policy Forms Don’t Do What You Think They Do

By Bill Wilson

Agency Checklists, MA Insurance News, Mass. Insurance News

Mass. Agent Op-Ed: My Volunteer Hurricane Relief Work After Hurricane Harvey

By AC Editor

Agency Checklists, MA Insurance News, Mass. Insurance, Lemonade, Lemonade Insurance Policy

InsurOp-Ed: Reverse Engineering – Making Lemons from Lemonade?

By Bill Wilson

View All

In Memoriam

Smiling older man with short hair wearing a black zip-front pullover, seated indoors at a table.

In Memoriam: Robert Pangione, 1935-2026

Mr. Haskell was a second-generation independent agent owner of the former Haskell Insurance Agency

In Memoriam: Patrick J. “P.J.” Haskell, 1966-2026

Mr. DeWolfe retired as Vice President of the Appleby & Wyman Insurance Agency

In Memoriam: Edward R. DeWolfe, 1940-2026

Footer

Contact us

We offer a variety of ways to get help promote your company or product.

Announcements
Email Sponsorships
Partnerships
Custom Collaborations

*Affiliate Disclosure

Please note that any of Agency Checklists’ articles might contain one or more affiliate links. This means that any subsequent purchase resulting from these links may result in a commission for us, but at no additional cost to you. For example, as an Amazon Associate, Agency Checklists earns a commission from all qualifying purchases. By working with affiliates we can continue to keep Agency Checklists subscription free. Thank you for your support.

Explore Our Archives

Copyright © 2026 · Agency Checklists · All rights reserved.

Loading Comments...