• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Contact Us
  • Post A Job

Agency Checklists

Massachusetts Insurance News & Job Opportunities

  • AC Interviews
  • Agency M&A
  • Career News
  • CAR News
  • DOI News
  • Coverage Cases
  • Innovation
  • InsurOp-Eds
  • AC Podcast
You are here: Home / Massachusetts Insurance News / Auto Insurance News / Triple I Report: Commercial Auto, Liability Claims Costs Surge Beyond Inflation

Triple I Report: Commercial Auto, Liability Claims Costs Surge Beyond Inflation

November 16, 2026 by Owen Gallagher

.

The U.S. property and casualty insurance industry reported its strongest underwriting results in more than a decade in 2025, posting a $68.7 billion underwriting gain and a combined ratio of 92.9%. But those favorable industrywide results contrasted with continued increases in liability claim costs that substantially exceeded general economic inflation.

Triple-I’s estimated inflation impact on liability insurance costs across four lines from 2016 to 2025
Triple-I estimates that inflation beyond ordinary economic inflation added $274.8 billion to $337 billion in losses and defense expenses across four U.S. liability lines from 2016 through 2025.

According to a new study by the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I), increasing inflation added an estimated $274.8 billion to $337 billion to liability insurance losses and defense and cost containment expenses between 2016 and 2025.

The study, Increasing Inflation Impact on Liability Insurance as of Year-End 2025, was published on November 12, 2026. It examines four major liability lines: personal auto, commercial auto, other liability (occurrence), and product liability (occurrence).

Authored by William Nibbelin, Triple-I’s head of industry data and actuarial research, the report found that increasing inflation accounted for between 16% and 19.6% of booked losses across the four lines during the 10-year period.

The findings represent a substantial increase over the institute’s previous study, which estimated additional costs of $231.6 billion to $281.2 billion for the 2015–2024 period.

The main driver was rising claim severity, not an increase in claim frequency. In several liability lines, average claim costs continued to rise even as claim frequency remained below pre-pandemic levels.

Commercial Auto and General Liability Show Significant Loss Increases

Commercial auto liability continues to experience some of the most pronounced increases in claim costs.

Triple-I estimated that increasing inflation added between $60.8 billion and $86 billion to commercial auto liability losses and defense expenses from 2016 through 2025. Those additional costs represented 24% to 34% of the line’s booked losses during the period, compared with 22.6% to 30.8% in the previous study.

Commercial auto claim severity increased at a compound annual rate of 8.2% from 2016 through 2025, even as claim frequency remained below pre-pandemic levels.

The study also identified continued deterioration in commercial auto loss development. Its measure of cumulative paid-loss development rose sharply between 2021 and 2023 and remained near that elevated level through 2025, indicating continued upward pressure on ultimate claim costs.

The largest estimated dollar impact, however, occurred in other liability (occurrence), a category that includes significant general liability exposures.

Triple-I estimated that increasing inflation added between $106.7 billion and $125 billion to losses and defense expenses in that line over the decade. These additional costs accounted for 31.4% to 36.8% of booked losses.

The study found that losses in other liability (occurrence) had increased 70.5% from 2017 levels.

Product liability (occurrence) also experienced substantial increases in claim costs. Although its overall dollar impact was smaller, claim severity increased at an annualized rate of 22.8% since 2016. Triple-I estimated that increasing inflation accounted for approximately 51.5% of the line’s booked losses in 2025 alone.

The report did not quantify increasing inflation’s impact on other liability or product liability written on a claims-made basis.

Personal Auto Liability Costs Also Continue to Rise

Personal auto liability accounted for a substantial portion of the estimated additional industry losses.

Triple-I calculated that increasing inflation added between $101.6 billion and $120.1 billion to personal auto liability losses and defense expenses from 2016 through 2025, representing 9.1% to 10.8% of booked losses.

The study found that personal auto bodily injury claim severity was 62.4% above pre-pandemic levels. Overall personal auto liability claim severity increased at a compound annual rate of 7.1% beginning in 2016.

At the same time, reported claim frequency relative to gross domestic product remained 46.1% below its 2016 level.

The divergence between claim frequency and severity is a central finding of the study. Although the frequency of claims remains comparatively low, the amounts insurers must pay to resolve those claims continue to increase.

Estimated Impact of Increasing Inflation by Liability Line

The following table summarizes Triple-I’s estimates for the 2016–2025 period.

Liability LineAdditional Losses and ExpensesShare of Booked Losses
Personal Auto Liability$101.6B–$120.1B9.1%–10.8%
Commercial Auto Liability$60.8B–$86.0B24.0%–34.0%
Other Liability – Occurrence$106.7B–$125.0B31.4%–36.8%
Product Liability – Occurrence$5.7B–$5.9B32.3%–33.6%
Total$274.8B–$337.0B16.0%–19.6%

Source: Insurance Information Institute, Increasing Inflation Impact on Liability Insurance as of Year-End 2025, Figure 2.

The estimates are based on an actuarial analysis of industry loss experience, including National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) Schedule P data and historical loss development patterns. The methodology compares actual losses with expected losses under selected historical development patterns.

The calculations measure the estimated additional costs associated with inflation beyond ordinary economic inflation. They do not separately quantify how much of the increase is attributable to individual factors such as litigation funding, larger jury verdicts, or other changes in the legal environment.

Rising Claim Costs Put Pressure on Umbrella and Excess Liability Coverage

The continuing increase in commercial auto and general liability claim severity also has implications for commercial umbrella and excess liability insurance.

An October 19, 2026, AM Best report on social inflation identified commercial auto liability as particularly affected by rising litigation costs, with implications extending to other liability lines.

The relationship between primary and excess liability coverage can magnify the financial effect of increasing claim severity.

For example, a liability claim originally valued at $950,000 would fall within a $1 million primary policy limit, assuming that limit remained fully available. A 10% increase in the claim’s ultimate cost would raise the loss to $1.045 million, potentially producing $45,000 in exposure above the primary limit.

That additional amount could fall to an umbrella or excess liability insurer, depending on the applicable policy terms and attachment requirements.

For commercial insurance agencies and brokers, the findings are relevant to discussions with insureds about primary liability limits, umbrella coverage, and the availability and pricing of excess limits.

Although Triple-I’s study does not examine Massachusetts insurance placements specifically, its findings provide additional context for the national loss trends influencing liability underwriting and pricing.

Massachusetts Insurers Face Additional Claim Settlement Exposure

For Massachusetts property and casualty insurers, rising liability claim severity also provides context for the financial consequences of unfair claim settlement practices under G.L. c. 176D and c. 93A.

The statutory exposure is distinct from the inflation costs measured by Triple-I. Nevertheless, the size of an underlying liability claim can have significant consequences when an insurer fails to effectuate a prompt, fair, and equitable settlement after liability has become reasonably clear.

A recent Massachusetts Superior Court Business Litigation Session decision illustrates that potential exposure.

As previously reported by Agency Checklists in Not Settling A “Reasonably Clear” Case Results in A $90 Million 93A Finding Against Liberty, the court ordered three Liberty Mutual insurance entities to pay more than $90.9 million for unfair claim settlement practices arising from a construction accident.

In Peerless Insurance Company v. Rooney, the court found that the insurers failed to properly evaluate and settle a claim after the insured’s liability had become reasonably clear.

The underlying personal injury action resulted in a $26.6 million jury verdict, which increased to more than $45 million with interest. The insurers subsequently offered their $19.5 million in available policy limits, but the offer came after the verdict.

The court’s decision demonstrates how statutory liability for unfair claim settlement practices can exceed the underlying insurance policy limits.

Although the Rooney judgment arose from an insurer’s claim handling conduct rather than the general inflation trends examined by Triple-I, both illustrate the financial significance of large liability claims for property and casualty insurers.

Triple-I’s updated findings indicate that these underlying claim costs have continued to increase, even during a period when the P&C industry’s aggregate underwriting results have improved substantially.

Primary Sidebar

  • NEW! BOSTON: Executive Director (Insurance Library)
  • BOSTON: In-House Legal Counsel (MPIUA)
  • QUINCY: State Manager – Personal Lines – Hybrid
  • QUINCY: Legal & Compliance Specialist – Hybrid  (Arbella)
  • LEOMINSTER: Commercial Lines Account Manager (DeCarolis)
  • BOSTON: Product Management Analyst (Safety)
  • DEDHAM: Senior Commercial Lines Underwriter (N&D)
  • SOUTHBOROUGH: Agency Development Representative (HMIC)
  • YARMOUTH: Employee Benefits Producer – Division Manager (Pioneer Insurance Partners)

Career News

Big ‘I’ Installs New Chair

Greg Melton joins Boston Mutual Life Insurance Company as Vice President of Communications, Marketing, and Events to align marketing priorities with the needs of broker partners, customers, and business objectives.

Boston Mutual Appoints Greg Melton as Vice President of Communications, Marketing, and Events

Michael Pezza, Executive Director of The Insurance Library in Boston

Executive Director Michael Pezza to Retire from The Insurance Library

View All

MA Division of Insurance Announcements

Interviews

From Nuptials, Tickets, and Taxes to Trusted Advisor: One Agency’s Unique Path to P&C Success

A Conversation with Evan Silverio, President & CEO of Silverio Insurance Group

Deland, Gibson Celebrates 125 Years: A Conversation with CEO Chip Gibson

The Fourth-Generation Family-Owned Agency is Based in Wellesley

Talking with Richard Welch: Growth and Innovation at Hospitality Mutual | Agency Checklists

Talking with Richard Welch: Growth and Innovation at Hospitality Mutual

Mr. Welch is CEO of Massachusetts-based Hospitality Insurance Group

Born and Bred in the Bay State: The Special Agent Story

Our Latest Agency Interview is with the Founder & President of Special Agent

A Conversation with Daniel C. Bridge – The 2023 Insurance Professional of the Year

Daniel Bridge is Board Chair, President, and CEO of Vermont Mutual Insurance Group

Making The Leap From Corporate to Entrepreneur: Nadeen Vella On Building NaVella Insurance From Scratch

Making The Leap From Corporate to Entrepreneur: Nadeen Vella On Building NaVella Insurance From Scratch

Our latest Agency Interview is with Nadeen Vella, the founder and owner of a virtual scratch independent agency.

View All

In Memoriam

Former Massachusetts insurance broker Joan Aslanian

In Memoriam: Joan A. Aslanian 1942-2026

In Memoriam: James P. Daley, 1959-2026

In Memoriam: Richard Sias, 1946-2026

InsurOp-Eds

InSurOp-Ed: On This Day 30 Years Ago: What I've Learned

InSurOp-Ed: On This Day 30 Years Ago: What I’ve Learned

By Matt Masiello

Should Insurance Agents Help Advocate Claims?

Should Agents Advocate For Insureds In Claim Denials?

By Bill Wilson

InSurOp-Ed: In Claim Disputes, Disregard Case Law At Your Own Risk

InSurOp-Ed: In Claim Disputes, Disregard Case Law At Your Own Risk

By Bill Wilson

InSurOp-Ed: Fried Chicken and Customer Loyalty

By Bill Wilson

View All

Footer

Contact us

We offer a variety of ways to get help promote your company or product.

Announcements
Email Sponsorships
Partnerships
Custom Collaborations

*Affiliate Disclosure

Please note that any of Agency Checklists’ articles might contain one or more affiliate links. This means that any subsequent purchase resulting from these links may result in a commission for us, but at no additional cost to you. For example, as an Amazon Associate, Agency Checklists earns a commission from all qualifying purchases. By working with affiliates we can continue to keep Agency Checklists subscription free. Thank you for your support.

Explore Our Archives

Copyright © 2026 · Agency Checklists · All rights reserved.

Loading Comments...