The insurance industry is changing, and independent insurance agencies are feeling it in real time. Costs are rising. Technology is moving fast. Finding and keeping the right people is not getting any easier. All of it adds up, and it shows up in the day-to-day more than ever before.
For many, the conversation is shifting. It is not just about staying independent. It is about what the next chapter looks like, and how to keep building something that lasts, not just for today, but for the long term.
More agency owners are reaching a point where they pause and take a closer look at what comes next. Not because something is broken, but because they have built something meaningful and want to be intentional about where it goes from here.
That was the case for Amy R. Morey of ARM Insurance Agency, who made the decision earlier this year to join a larger organization, MountainOne.
“This really wasn’t about fixing anything,” Amy said. “Things were going well. It just felt like one of those moments where you stop and look around and ask, what’s next?”
She described it as a pivot, not away from something, but toward something.
“You can keep doing what you’ve always done, or you can take a step toward something that opens up more opportunity,” she said. “For me, it was about finding a way to grow without trying to carry everything on my own.”
That balance is something many independent insurance agencies are working through. Running an agency today takes more than relationships and industry knowledge. There is a growing list of responsibilities behind the scenes, from compliance and carrier relationships to marketing, technology, and staffing. Over time, those demands can begin to compete with the work that owners value most.
“For me, it came down to having more support where I needed it,” Amy added. “Marketing, technology, staffing, just having people you can lean on. It lets you take a step back and focus on your clients again.”
That idea of getting time back is coming up more often across the industry. Not because owners want to do less, but because they want to be more intentional about where they spend their energy.
A similar perspective came from Mark McClure of McClure Insurance Agency, who made a similar decision in 2024 to join MountainOne.
“A big part of it for me was my staff,” Mark shared. “You look at where things are headed, and you want to make sure your team is in a good place long term. That mattered just as much as anything else.”
For many agency owners, that responsibility to their team is a driving force. These are people who have helped build the business, supported clients, and contributed to the culture over time. Making sure they have stability and opportunity moving forward is not something taken lightly.
Mark also pointed back to what makes independent insurance agencies strong in the first place.
“You don’t want to lose what you built,” he said. “The relationships, the trust, the way you take care of people. That’s the whole thing. The idea is to keep that, and just have more support behind you.”
That tension, protecting what makes an agency unique while figuring out how to evolve, is where many owners are spending their time right now.
Independence still matters. The connection to the community, the personal relationships, the reputation that takes years to build, those things do not go away. In many ways, they are more important than ever.
At the same time, expectations are changing. Clients expect more accessibility, faster service, and more digital convenience. Carriers are evolving. Competition is not just down the street anymore. All of it creates a different kind of operating environment than even a few years ago.
As a result, more independent insurance agencies are exploring what partnership can look like. Not as a last resort, but as a proactive decision. One that allows them to maintain what makes their agency strong, while gaining the support needed to continue growing.
There is no single reason that leads someone to take that step. For some, it is succession planning. For others, it is about supporting their team, expanding capabilities, or simply finding a more sustainable way to operate.
But there is a common thread. It is about taking something that already works and making sure it continues, with the right support in place.
The future of independent insurance agencies is not about giving something up. It is about building on what is already there, and making sure it is positioned for what comes next.
For independent agency owners thinking about the future, it may be worth exploring what that next step could look like, including what partnership with an organization like MountainOne can offer.
Jonathan Denmark
President and chief operating officer of MountainOne Insurance Agency, Inc.
To reach Mr. Denmark, please use one of the links below:
